3 similar challenges, different results


#1

TLDR: OF 3 challenges I started, 1 passed, 2 survived. Motivations were really similar. So I’m questioning the whales staking tons of tokens to vote for…

I also already staked 2 relative POIs with my own corrections nearby the survived POIs. So now I’m waiting for somebody to challenge mines or the other.

Crepes On Cole link here
The reason of the challenge was:

“Website missing https://www.crepesoncole.com Address is incorrect, from their website is on the other street, as for the entrance: 3906, 100 Carl St, San Francisco, CA 94117, United States”

The POI has been judged as VALID. Please give me some feedback on this if you voted against because I don’t get it why this should be VALID.

United States Postal Service link here
Reason of the challenge was:

Incorrect location, the POI is pointing to a parking lot. the Postal Service building is northern, as you can check on their website or any map, right in front of the pizzeria, not in front of Cues Billiard. proof here https://www.google.com/maps/place/United+States+Postal+Service/@33.1448215,-117.1630244,142m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m5!3m4!1s0x80db8aa4d80a45dd:0x96bbf9eda306e82d!8m2!3d33.1450856!4d-117.1631317 and here https://www.mapquest.com/us/ca/san-marcos/92069-1709/420-n-twin-oaks-valley-rd-33.144705,-117.162521 Also the tag Residential hasn’t any sense for the service given. A more objective description for this kind of POI would also be cool.

The POI has been judged as VALID. Please give me some feedback on this if you voted against because I don’t get it why this should be VALID.

Innovative Microscopes link here
Reason of the challenge : `

" Incorrect building & location, the correct building is the rectangle shaped north-east from this trapezoid where POI was placed. Proof on their website at this page https://www.innoscopes.com/contact other proof here https://www.google.com/maps/@33.1531454,-117.1621248,3a,15y,4.31h,87.67t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sev37U07_yFGmJgY06xinaQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 I’m gonna add it now the correct one."

Aaand this one was judged INVALID. As you can see the main point was an incorrect location.

I really hope somebody of the voters could explain here their reasons because that’s really annoying.
ça va sans dire, I’m gonna keep on challenging and make my job as a cartographer, voter and verifier.


#2

I remember assessing these challenges on May 2nd.

Website missing https://www.crepesoncole.com (:heavy_check_mark: confirmed) Address is incorrect (:heavy_check_mark: confirmed), from their website is on the other street, as for the entrance: 3906, 100 Carl St, San Francisco, CA 94117, United States

Incorrect building & location (:heavy_check_mark: confirmed), the correct building is the rectangle shaped north-east from this trapezoid where POI was placed. Proof on their website at this page https://www.innoscopes.com/contact other proof here https://www.google.com/maps/@33.1531454,-117.1621248,3a,15y,4.31h,87.67t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sev37U07_yFGmJgY06xinaQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 I’m gonna add it now the correct one (:red_circle: don’t see any so far).

Incorrect location, the POI is pointing to a parking lot (:heavy_check_mark: confirmed). the Postal Service building is northern, as you can check on their website or any map, right in front of the pizzeria, not in front of Cues Billiard. proof here https://www.google.com/maps/place/United+States+Postal+Service/@33.1448215,-117.1630244,142m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m5!3m4!1s0x80db8aa4d80a45dd:0x96bbf9eda306e82d!8m2!3d33.1450856!4d-117.1631317 and here https://www.mapquest.com/us/ca/san-marcos/92069-1709/420-n-twin-oaks-valley-rd-33.144705,-117.162521 Also the tag Residential hasn’t any sense for the service given. A more objective description for this kind of POI would also be cool. (:small_orange_diamond: a bunch of generally correct, though nitpicky, points)

In the end I was not strongly moved by these challenges either way and decided to abstain from voting.


#3

didn’t think should be challenged for the full amount due to those reasons. Wrong tag can be chalked up to either a user error or something that could be fixed when editing points exists. the parking lot is for the post office. What would the address be of that parking lot? The same as the post office. If you went to the address in the point you would be at the post office so not a very attractive challenge when for full amount and without a better quality point being there already.

why not challenge for less than maximum and or add a better point as cartographer to better rally support for what you think are valid challenges?


#4

Exactly what I made before on the first challenges in Girona(Spain). Voters apparently doesn’t care about it.

Location of a building is the building, the relative parking lot theory sounds captious,I can’t really get on this because to me is Crystal clear - the description of the POI is a postal service with specific informations about a building location. I’m expecting the POI point to be inside the building at least. That’s cartographer common sense .

The new point is there i5 think, challenge me if you dare :smiley:


#5

Is there since days man! Check it out, obviously in the right location :grin:


#6

Don’t argue with that, I could have missed it on May 2nd. It would be easier if the challenge said “I added a better point at https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x397c2fa0640111bc68429838b7de211fe5d86ca842ecc1e148111355b3b6a213/?lng=-117.1624485&lat=33.1528329&zoom=17.50


#7

Just to inform all of the interested cartographers I challenged again the USPS - find it here
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x0eb7526b55e631f22f62de1ec31e878c39457c01b2cc4582f63c12ea457f5ba2/?lng=-117.1629220&lat=33.1444455&zoom=15.00
I’m really interested in the output of this challenge, I verified a POI with (according to me) the right location and a more objective description.
I assume that anybody willing to oppose to this challenge will open a challenge against the POI I added… let’s see!
Feedbacks (and votes) highly appreciated.