45 Challanges Pack - between 50 and 2000


#1

In order to make this joint project better, I set very high standards for myself and the creation of my POIs.

That’s what I expect from other POIs.

Therefore, I am not satisfied with some inadequate Google entries and inadequately described POIs.

A full address with postcode or or if not avaible at least one country or city where the POI is located I think is the least we can expect from a database of the future.

Since the love is in the detail I have also worked out some very fine information to improve the POIs even more.

You will find a link to many entries that makes your decision easier.

Thanks for your attention and have fun voting.

Greetings Elvo

1
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x4038a3121aafd8ed9e8a725136f0605fa4545428399eb54145b57a8c7c64c232/?lng=12.9983166&lat=47.7909524&zoom=15.00
2
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xb5059f8516ec446d7ad5353dcd3dbe215bc7ef59e3e064c6793a8ea796cd6ec9/?lng=15.9910477&lat=46.6763110&zoom=15.00
3
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x74682becc94cc8b65ac8ab446ecc995703996ad6363dc949734739c14ee74a63/?lng=15.9894498&lat=46.6764776&zoom=15.00
4
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xf2f77248a01302a1261db8adaabafa6cb53435714ebea5d36309c0fe7d6839c5/?lng=12.9982288&lat=47.8163734&zoom=15.00
5
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xbb6d40afccfa9f1e035e5a579704caf45e6d72ed5c655b6a281771d62aa234cd/?lng=20.4460121&lat=44.7971206&zoom=15.00
6
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xd6080b913216e8399aa3c17d9e481ea5151e94db196e628561cbf05c7d58cea7/?lng=11.8014825&lat=46.6393917&zoom=15.00
7
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xea542e139a75566617f62ea1c577c32fcf675c3869a51c5d62bf667321ebc2d5/?lng=11.8046397&lat=46.6353292&zoom=15.00
8
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xb2923761d30b1c534894d0587bf80dcee05634af234526f746e988d2b8acee25/?lng=19.0653511&lat=47.5006048&zoom=15.00
9
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x8ffe9ef92cd88e7c2a65ee129f4daf42f11661e60b1aa4e5c11d09796c5dc232/?lng=19.0463520&lat=47.5072059&zoom=15.00
10
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x0070d548030d5b69036b50833ef095d383f3e50972c1943eabc918193d4def79/?lng=19.0539114&lat=47.5008083&zoom=15.00
11
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xf9a00d8d65e53ed503c94545d1839f5b9d5b69ab5e7a5a3c777c4a6b5fa9df3c/?lng=19.0556415&lat=47.5105979&zoom=15.00
12
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xb63d8a08c660f45263eb77882acbe126a1bfef0676a6414e6992bfd13759fd2d/?lng=19.0583317&lat=47.5027703&zoom=15.00
13
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xda531e2897dc6f07553878ef3bf072263bb3bcf57fb7a1954f6b9946324398bc/?lng=19.0434746&lat=47.5148726&zoom=15.00
14
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x10a7622e57bc934e0403438bc12e58b0f326e1bb9a183efe6ba4e31ae6759699/?lng=19.0504437&lat=47.5041926&zoom=15.00
15
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x69b4039ad0221bf1b16881a2cc067df1f6c02cbb551bf5036fc8c58e2bcdd97c/?lng=19.0592286&lat=47.5131981&zoom=15.00
16
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x63c1b5512c47ade4e5285aebe9c354fc6d3245dc7a66d8a0bff7b10b6657c7b9/?lng=19.0819915&lat=47.5183637&zoom=15.00
17
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x9b5d4f8ad0ac193f8efff271728c9b5d14fd3ff1e33804ab4e5a72b9a332e604/?lng=19.0772466&lat=47.5148791&zoom=15.00
18
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x83f034e9c9bed3f517510e03a5c6d8697572ba7d1382ae33065ddbd417285938/?lng=19.0635235&lat=47.5052354&zoom=15.00
19
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x24d27586d4780f584d00782f8784381d96f11258c69e85780a3cd2a60032acae/?lng=15.6507421&lat=46.5558290&zoom=15.00
20
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xa94ab87712d3c0abec5b8deb738e7fea708a98e2fae2e030845a41f9c7012a44/?lng=15.6460522&lat=46.5577295&zoom=15.00
21
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xf9188333f1d36d58f01066599da689707045daa2a1980fbb1dfc9687114b6131/?lng=15.6517965&lat=46.5541928&zoom=15.00
22
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x06b186e0b0284ac422549ce360c5a7ebc0ad12544947a2cc9d2ad2af92f84303/?lng=14.1858352&lat=47.8491384&zoom=15.00
23
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x8fb874f19a6f59ce776ef11aaf1ae10d55d093f301dac1507ee2981ec098b9fa/?lng=14.2555253&lat=47.8863938&zoom=15.00
24
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x8271540d5a956e7ae7ccc063040cc5c896a76521101c66ccd5f04cc29378f541/?lng=14.2573875&lat=47.8860744&zoom=15.00
25
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x0f7d30c222726a19e9dfddbc6fca2756a295d3ad89f82dc19de3041ec81f185b/?lng=20.4253893&lat=44.7709394&zoom=15.00
26
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xc9689fedae18a43375c431e79a36f1219e0a5322ffa38ac47d45f36b86fec5af/?lng=20.3825842&lat=44.7799258&zoom=15.00
27
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x3305e02a1fe138ce13e79ab105ad30c1d1a8bdf27c700be072e68ac98d2448a6/?lng=20.4475715&lat=44.8238985&zoom=15.00
28
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x266af48a2a68758c1464fa658b898ed4634b671f629e19cce3192b0737b524df/?lng=14.3577849&lat=46.2463251&zoom=15.00
29
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xb69b4de0d4983f170d98df4499eb99727727802d0e454bd4a8366ba86c244af1/?lng=16.4168343&lat=48.2357059&zoom=15.00
30
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x42d9ee96453ef51641f8e7a9e0e3bb606f007c23fff5c0b769f1382c886495df/?lng=16.3761076&lat=48.1983851&zoom=15.00
31
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x2725c1d873f238753c94eb1f434c674fb9d1bcc412ff12aa7717ecd56330be68/?lng=15.9873140&lat=46.6824130&zoom=15.00
32
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x9fba45d93c584dfe7c87d1b9aa39d02fcc0d1cd1a3bbd50b27c1fae1b5ad9b78/?lng=15.9871887&lat=46.6837556&zoom=15.00
33
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x0ad388871b48e6799f4b3f617d75cdd3cdf786403c7f6ab597f828b689ea4178/?lng=15.9986715&lat=46.6765257&zoom=15.00
34
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xe3f69053d2b0af7c3ae853cd32fae1573de92b4837ec2d579aa68c699781b4f8/?lng=14.5241073&lat=46.0812547&zoom=15.00
35
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xd6b4b32464362bcafa99556a8e9ede52a61d3a9ff9a4041b1ce56d18571c4288/?lng=14.5104294&lat=46.0580123&zoom=15.00
36
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x973927708cb0125aa4de41a2c0d3d48f7c9e9727ee39bb1246dca661cacf6e7c/?lng=15.6402583&lat=46.5627179&zoom=15.00
37
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xb3c67667479b9a8ac5484e13a75a4a67193b61411bc88085b53d9488c1f8e1ce/?lng=14.5087389&lat=46.0692686&zoom=15.00
38
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x30555cc9c6ab77ada6b91e2341a55503b99c31e753108c2a26a4c09aef25edec/?lng=15.6430716&lat=46.5592312&zoom=15.00
49
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x6b29a347c45cfc202124b9877b8bc34dff9c033e4692b88ca5e54554cec3428b/?lng=19.8453891&lat=45.2593881&zoom=15.00
40
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xc3dd4948cd2f2ba5955de522803222858baf123fa7a40ccd3185a164efb72ec1/?lng=14.5082263&lat=46.0609738&zoom=15.00
41
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x866838dd45d05752c6b701c271869877ea762660016303a5ef908ff709031c03/?lng=14.5139542&lat=46.0646092&zoom=15.00
42
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0xa903ef5e8203d6272330087ce90ac673d46256240f07b0b6144743e2664faa13/?lng=14.5121976&lat=46.0643420&zoom=15.00
43
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x550d3738a9d472af89f1b9b226eb71a31e41d42f12d5c01837219f76187b9f70/?lng=32.7990716&lat=39.9309323&zoom=15.00
44
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x2b92e8facd14697d2ecb8604ab7c38c05689af2c3bea43371c0f52c41cda7865/?lng=16.3726114&lat=48.2086865&zoom=15.00
45
https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x24468f4e27e5f6b5fd9b0f744992061080666f38d8f38b9b2bcc157d59569ec9/?lng=8.5641320&lat=47.4501457&zoom=15.00


#2

That’s nice and you probably put some time and effort into finding these discrepancies.

I’m not always sure how you would want the challenged POIs look. For example, on your list is a bus stop challenged for its address - how should a bus stop address look? Do they even have postal addresses in the same way buildings do?

So why not add correctly formatted POIs next to the challenged ones, to better demonstrate your high standards and goodwill?


#3

The reason is City, number ore postal code missing.
Here it is more likely the missing city in the address field.

But no matter. A postal code can also be used to better locate a POI in a district to which you can assign the postal code.
I would always add the postal code if available.

Here two bus stations with almost identical name and in two cities of the same name. The postcode is the only thing that gives clarity at first sight.

Volksschule, 8953 Gmünd

https://www.google.at/maps/place/Gm%C3%BCnd+in+Ktn+Volksschule/@46.9071563,13.5374795,17z/data=!4m8!1m2!2m1!1sbusstatiion+gm%C3%BCnd!3m4!1s0x0:0x84212e497ce9a430!8m2!3d46.9078989!4d13.5397375

Volksschule1, 3950 Gmünd

https://www.google.com/maps/place/Gm%C3%BCnd+N%C3%96+Volksschule+1/@48.7702153,14.986665,15.43z/data=!4m15!1m9!2m8!1sgm%C3%BCnd+busstation!3m6!1sgm%C3%BCnd+busstation!2zR23DvG5k!3s0x4773211bb819f215:0xeca52cd3609fc857!4m2!1d14.98511!2d48.77156!3m4!1s0x0:0xe7a1827ad59c6c06!8m2!3d48.767425!4d14.9872693


#4

@Elvo hello. I have been a bit caught up in other affairs, but will look more into your challenges.

I agree with @foamspacer the community consensus is that aggressive challenging without adding points is a detracting factor when evaluating for voter support.

It was discussed prior but can be said again geolocation and geocoding is unsolved and debatable as is. like one map will have a city encoded one way another another. Like we saw in challenges over encoding in Brooklyn. Foam map uses map box open street map for the interface and to assist in filling out info. My experience is that this service is subpar and just goes to show potential value of foam.

yes cartographers should be diligent in their efforts but we can also assess when issues in PoIs touch on general unsolved issues in geospatial like geocoding address and point placement and see that these can be upgraded when data can be edited after adding a point.

My first reaction is that I am not in favor of these challenges


#5

Thanks for the contribution.

In my opinion, the number of specific information of a POI increases its value as an infomation carrier. The more information the more useful.

Of course we can assume that data can be corrected in the future. That’s probably possible with the number of POIs today.
But I see it as very critical for the future when the daily creation of POIs increases a lot.
When we dont get the best possible level of accuracy from the beginning of the day, we’ll need more people to control and challenge.

When I build something stable like a good house, I set an accuracy from the beginning onwards so as not to be preoccupied with corrections or demolition work later on.

If we talk about proof then we maybe think about proof of information.

Many owners of the POIs I challenged did not even bother to do that. And for example, I’m talking about opening a given link to see if the address is correct.

I look forward to your opinion on the challenges as they are very different.


#6

what is your standing as a Cartographer on the leaderboard? Are you contributing to the Map? Why are you so concerned about the accuracy if not a Cartographer?

I see you added a two points, but 45 challenges? Why not add better points. Some of your challenges are good and appreciate the time you put into the reasoning for example

Hochstrahlbrunnen

The description suggests that the fountain would also have something to do with the Red Army. The high-beam well has nothing to do with the Red Army. It was put into operation in 1873 on the occasion of the completion of the first Viennese high spring water pipeline by Emperor Franz Joseph 1st. The address should also only be Schwarzenbergplatz because the fountain is located in the middle. Schwarzenbergplatz 7 is across the street. The POI would have to be called only Schwarzenbergplatz and include in the description of the fountain as well as the monument.

https://map.foam.space/#/dashboard/0x42d9ee96453ef51641f8e7a9e0e3bb606f007c23fff5c0b769f1382c886495df/?lng=16.3761076&lat=48.1983851&zoom=13.00


#7

Understand your question in part.

It all happened on the first day I started working with the map. I first created POIs before started to challenge some.

And while looking at other POIs, of course, I was looking for inspiration on the one hand, but also very quickly noticed that a lot of inaccurate or poorly registered here.
So I sat until the morning hours and searched all over Europe.

But with a POI that is deficient at first glance, I do not need to go deeper.

If food dont taste good at first I do not ask about the ingredients but if it tastes good to me it will be interesting.

That’s why there are some challanges with more description others less.
When there are POIs easy and fast created without complete information about adress or any proof of information why should it not be easy the same way to challange them?

On the ratio of created POIs and challenged on the first day, I can only say that the time used for both has the same value. That’s why there are the different tasks.
But everyone should evaluate how he wants it. If someone thinks this work is worthless, that’s just it.
Described in the guide is that you can do both and both serve to improve the map.

Thank you for your attention. I am very happy that someone has taken the time.


#8

A new weekend is approaching and I have a day off soon.

I will create a new POI for each Challenge won with the Tokens of Challenges. Promised!

In the best case, you can expect 45 interesting posts including full and accurate address as well as a detailed description and everything that goes with it.

And to show something else, I will work out some of the POIs with my daughter so we can see which places our kids are so interested in.

Greetings Elvo